Menu Top


Global Environmental & Resource Issues

Environment And Natural Resources (Chapter Title)

Environment and Natural Resources** in the context of global politics focuses on the challenges and dynamics related to the management, conservation, and distribution of the Earth's natural resources and the environment as a whole.

It examines how environmental issues, such as pollution, resource depletion, and climate change, have become critical concerns in international relations, influencing state policies, global cooperation, and the rise of environmental movements.


Environmental Concerns In Global Politics

Environmental issues have increasingly become central to global politics due to their transnational nature and their profound impact on:

  • Human Survival: Issues like climate change, pollution, and resource depletion directly threaten human well-being and survival.
  • Economic Stability: Environmental degradation can disrupt agricultural production, damage infrastructure, and lead to significant economic losses.
  • Political Stability: Resource scarcity, environmental disasters, and climate-induced migration can exacerbate existing political tensions, lead to conflict, and destabilize regions.
  • International Cooperation: Many environmental problems require collective action and cooperation among states, as they do not respect national borders.
  • Global Commons: Issues related to the environment often involve "global commons" – resources or areas that belong to no single state but are shared by all, such as the oceans, atmosphere, and Antarctica.

Global politics now grapples with balancing national economic development with environmental protection and sustainability.


The Protection Of Global Commons

Global commons** are resources or areas that lie outside the political reach of any one nation and are considered the common heritage of humankind. Their protection is a shared responsibility.

  • Examples:
    • Atmosphere: The air surrounding the Earth, crucial for life.
    • Oceans: Vast bodies of water covering most of the Earth's surface, containing diverse marine life and important for global trade and climate regulation.
    • Outer Space: The region beyond Earth's atmosphere, used for satellites, space exploration, and astronomy.
    • Antarctica: A continent covered in ice, important for scientific research and its role in global climate systems.
  • Challenges in Protection: Protecting global commons is difficult because:
    • Tragedy of the Commons: Individual actors (states or corporations) may overuse or degrade these resources for their own short-term benefit, harming the collective long-term interest.
    • Lack of Central Authority: There is no single global authority to enforce rules or manage these resources effectively.
    • Differing Interests: Nations often have conflicting interests regarding the exploitation and conservation of global commons.
  • International Cooperation: Protecting global commons requires international cooperation through treaties, agreements, and organizations (like the UN) to establish rules, monitor activities, and promote sustainable practices.

Common But Differentiated Responsibilities

The principle of "Common But Differentiated Responsibilities" (CBDR)** is a cornerstone of international environmental negotiations, particularly concerning climate change.

  • Core Idea: It recognizes that all countries share a common responsibility to protect the global environment, but acknowledges that they have contributed differently to environmental problems and possess varying capacities to address them.
  • Historical Responsibility: Developed countries (often referred to as 'Global North') are recognized as having historically contributed the most to environmental problems like greenhouse gas emissions due to their industrialization processes.
  • Capacity to Respond: Developing countries (often referred to as 'Global South') often have fewer financial resources, less advanced technology, and greater immediate developmental needs, which limits their capacity to undertake costly environmental measures.
  • Implications: CBDR suggests that developed countries should take the lead in reducing emissions and providing financial and technological assistance to developing countries to help them pursue sustainable development pathways.
  • Controversy: The principle is sometimes debated, with developed nations arguing for more uniform global commitments and developing nations emphasizing their right to develop and their historical lack of contribution to current environmental crises.

CBDR is central to discussions on climate justice and equitable global environmental governance.


Common Property Resources

Common Property Resources (CPRs)** are resources that are owned, managed, and utilized by a community or group of users, rather than being privately owned or solely state-owned.

  • Definition: CPRs are resources whose ownership and use are governed by shared rules and norms agreed upon by a community. Examples include village ponds, grazing lands, forests, and traditional fishing grounds.
  • Traditional Management: Historically, many communities had sophisticated systems for managing CPRs sustainably, based on customary laws, community norms, and collective decision-making.
  • Threats: CPRs face threats from:
    • State Policies: Government policies that privatize common lands or bring them under state control without consulting local communities.
    • Overexploitation: Increased population pressure or commercial exploitation can lead to overuse and degradation of CPRs.
    • Lack of Recognition: When traditional community management systems are not recognized or supported by the state.
  • Importance: CPRs are vital for the livelihoods of many rural populations, particularly the poor and marginalized, providing essential resources like fuel, fodder, food, and water.
  • Environmental Impact: Sustainable management of CPRs is crucial for local environmental health and biodiversity.

The recognition and strengthening of community management of CPRs are often advocated as a key strategy for both environmental conservation and social equity.


India’s Stand On Environmental Issues

India's position on global environmental issues is shaped by its developmental needs, its commitment to equity, and its historical context.

  • Commitment to Sustainable Development: India emphasizes the need for sustainable development, balancing economic growth with environmental protection.
  • CBDR Advocate: India is a strong proponent of the principle of "Common But Differentiated Responsibilities," arguing that developed countries, with their historical emissions and greater capacity, should take the lead in climate action.
  • Right to Development: India stresses its right to development and lifting its large population out of poverty, arguing that it needs resources and flexibility to achieve this while transitioning to cleaner technologies.
  • Renewable Energy Push: India has made significant commitments to renewable energy, particularly solar power, and is actively working to increase its share of clean energy in its energy mix.
  • Forest and Biodiversity Protection: India has a strong commitment to protecting its vast forest cover and biodiversity, with laws like the Forest Conservation Act and the Biological Diversity Act.
  • International Agreements: India has participated actively in international environmental negotiations, including the Rio Summit (1992), the Kyoto Protocol, and the Paris Agreement, advocating for global cooperation while safeguarding its national interests.

Environmental Movements: One Or Many?

The question of whether environmental movements are "one or many"** reflects the diverse nature and origins of environmental activism.

  • Many Movements: In reality, there are numerous environmental movements, each with its specific focus, goals, and geographical context.
    • Issue-Specific: Movements focused on specific issues like anti-pollution (e.g., against industrial discharge), conservation (e.g., protecting forests, wildlife), anti-dam protests (e.g., Narmada Bachao Andolan), or movements against specific development projects.
    • Region-Specific: Movements that arise from local environmental concerns unique to a particular region or community (e.g., Chipko Movement in the Himalayas, movements in the North-East protecting tribal lands and forests).
    • Focus on Livelihoods: Many movements are driven by communities whose livelihoods depend directly on natural resources, linking environmental protection with social justice.
  • Common Threads: Despite their diversity, these movements often share common underlying principles:
    • Protecting Nature: A shared concern for the preservation of the natural environment.
    • Questioning Development Models: A critique of development paradigms that prioritize economic growth at the expense of ecological sustainability and social equity.
    • Rights of Local Communities: Asserting the rights of local populations, particularly indigenous peoples, over their environment and resources.
    • Challenging Corporate and State Power: Often opposing the actions of corporations or government policies that are seen as detrimental to the environment.

Therefore, while there isn't one monolithic environmental movement, there is a broad and diverse ecosystem of environmental activism addressing a wide range of interconnected issues.


Resource Geopolitics

Resource Geopolitics** refers to the strategic importance of natural resources in shaping international relations, power dynamics, and conflicts between states.

  • Strategic Resources: Control over vital resources like oil, water, minerals, and fertile land can provide states with significant economic and geopolitical leverage.
  • Competition and Conflict: Competition for scarce resources, such as water or energy, can be a major source of tension and conflict between nations. Examples include disputes over water sharing in river basins or competition for oil reserves.
  • Resource Dependence: Countries that are heavily dependent on importing certain resources may find their foreign policy constrained by the policies of resource-supplying nations.
  • Geopolitical Influence: States that control strategically important resources can exert influence over others, shaping international diplomacy and alliances.
  • Environmental Impact on Geopolitics: Climate change and resource depletion can exacerbate geopolitical instability by creating climate refugees, triggering resource wars, and altering global power balances.

Understanding resource geopolitics is essential for comprehending many contemporary international relations issues.


The Indigenous Peoples And Their Rights

Indigenous Peoples** are communities that have a historical continuity with pre-invasion and pre-colonial societies that developed on their territories, now often identified as nations or distinct geographical areas. They have their own distinct cultures, languages, traditions, and often maintain close ties to their ancestral lands and resources.

  • Marginalization: Indigenous peoples have often faced marginalization, dispossession, and discrimination throughout history due to colonialism, development projects, and the expansion of nation-states.
  • Loss of Land and Resources: Their traditional lands and the natural resources within them are often coveted for development purposes (mining, dams, logging), leading to displacement and loss of livelihood.
  • Cultural Threats: Their distinct cultures, languages, and identities are often threatened by assimilationist policies or the dominant societal norms.
  • Struggle for Rights: Indigenous peoples globally, and in India (referred to as Adivasis), have actively struggled to assert their rights, including:
    • Right to Land: Recognition and protection of their ancestral land rights.
    • Right to Self-Determination: The right to govern their own affairs and manage their resources according to their own customs and laws.
    • Cultural Preservation: The right to maintain and practice their unique cultures, languages, and traditions.
    • Right to Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC): The principle that indigenous communities should be consulted and give their consent before any project affecting their lands or resources is undertaken.
  • International Recognition: The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), adopted in 2007, provides an international framework for recognizing and protecting these rights.

Addressing the rights and aspirations of indigenous peoples is a crucial aspect of achieving social justice and sustainable development globally.